no perscription maxalt next day where can i purchase cytotec finpecia cipla buy buy requip usa where is the best place to buy generic finasteride buy requip line buy finasteride at walmart buy orlistat cheap buy finasteride from usa where to buy bactrim can i buy finasteride over the counter uk buy prednisone uk where to buy prednisone uk order ampicillin orlistat without prescription in canada seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg purchase overnight delivery generic cytotec 200 mcg without prescription canada buy generic requip 1 mg online no prescription no prescription generic premarin 0.625 mg purchase generic premarin 0.625 mg online cytotec 200 mcg purchase overnight delivery order metformin 500 mg online consultation cheap generic metformin 500 mg no prescription orlistat 120 mg for sale usa generic finasteride 1 mg without a precsriptions buy generic maxalt 5 mg online generic finasteride 1 mg from india cytotec 200 mcg cost buy maxalt 5 mg australia no prescription can i buy cytotec at walgreens can i get cytotec without rx can i buy cytotec in boots buy cytotec online usa where can i buy cytotec here in the philippines can you buy cytotec at cvs i need to order cytotec without a prescription where to buy cytotec in doha cytotec no prescription where i can buy cytotec in cebu cytotec where can i buy it where can i buy cytotec pills in south africa where can i buy cytotec philippines where to buy cytotec in oman how to get cytotec buy cytotec in uk canadian pharmacy no prescription cytotec buy cytotec in saudi arabia cheap cytotec philippines where can i buy cytotec in malaysia where can i buy cytotec over the counter in cebu cheap cytotec online no prescription purchase cheap generic cytotec cytotec cheap online canadian pharmacy cytotec abortion pill buy online where to buy cytotec in hong kong where can i purchase cytotec buy cytotec next day delivery where can i buy cytotec pills in the philippines where did you buy cytotec where can i buy cytotec in laguna order cytotec online in philippines can i buy cytotec over the counter in uk buy cytotec uk where to buy cytotec maxalt cheap no membership where can i buy cytotec for abortion cheap maxalt without rx seroquel 12.5 mg purchase bactrim online orlistat 60mg requip purchase order metformin 500 mg online buy maxalt without prescription maxalt without prescription overnight shipping where can i buy real finasteride online buy prednisone 5 mg buy maxalt online consultation us buy finasteride finasteride australia arimidex for men orlistat 120 mg express online buy cheap prednisone online where to buy cytotec pills in south africa buy cytotec uae buy cytotec thailand where can i buy cytotec in thailand seroquel 400 mg buy prednisone mastercard buy stromectol pills premarin buy orlistat online without script can you buy finasteride in mexico premarin .3 mgs seroquel 400 mg price buy generic metformin propranolol purchase canada where to buy cytotec in jeddah how to buy cytotec in malaysia finpecia 1 mg premarin 0.625 mg purchase canada buy prednisone 20 mg with no prescription order cytotec 200 mcg mastercard metformin 500 mg cheapest place to order buy discounted lisinopril 5 mg online metformin 500 mg online sale without prescription i need to order lisinopril 5 mg without a prescription buy metformin 500 mg online made in america lisinopril 5 mg generic no prescription order orlistat 120 mg overnight seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg overnight without prescription were to buy orlistat 120 mg seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg online purchase lisinopril 5 mg tablets 200 mcg no prescription australia order prednisone for dogs online order prednisone for dogs where to order prednisone buy genuine prednisone in the u.s. buy prednisolone prednisone online purchase where can i buy prednisone without prescriptions prednisolone 5mg buy online where to buy prednisolone for dogs buying prednisone online without prescription buy prednisone 5 mg buy prednisone 20mg tablets buy prednisone online no prescription prednisone prescription cost prednisone online sale without prescription where can i get prednisone buy oral prednisone generic prednisone prednisone express online buy prednisone without a prescription prednisone precio where to buy cytotec in davao city how to buy cytotec in cebu where to buy cytotec online best place to buy cytotec online? order cytotec cytotec without a perscription cytotec cheapest place to order cheap generic prednisone can i order prednisone online buy generic prednisone buy prednisone cheap without perscription were to buy prednisone prednisone 10mg buy purchase prednisolone tablets can you order prednisone online where can i get cytotec to buy order cytotec no prescription i want to buy pregnizone without a prescription where to buy cytotec pills in dubai cytotec online without prescription where can you buy bactrim where can i buy bactrim ds buy cheap finasteride online requip best buy where to buy cytotec pills in south africa buy cytotec cebu buy proscar online ireland buy finasteride 5mg purchase maxalt without prescription needed buy cytotec now where to buy cytotec pills in the philippines where to buy prednisone 5mg buy maxalt online no membership buy metformin for horses premarin 1.25mg dosage order requip 1 mg online consultation get premarin 0.625 mg without prescription cheapest online indian pharmacy for finpecia 1 mg or generic buy generic requip 1 mg online buy premarin 0.625 mg india generic requip 1 mg online orlistat 120 mg over the counter premarin 0.625 mg online sale without prescription best place to buy maxalt 5 mg online? no prescription generic requip 1 mg cytotec 200 mcg oral tablet no prescription discount cheap prednisone 20 mg no prescription premarin 0.625 mg without script where can i buy cytotec 200 mcg over the counter order finpecia 1 mg without rx seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg to buy in canada buy cytotec in uae orlistat order online canada maxalt over night orlistat lesofat maxalt with no rx and free shipping us maxalt without prescription buy metformin tablets buy finasteride australia purchase maxalt pay pal online without rx orlistat without perscription uk buy requip online now buy bactrim suspension where to buy lisinopril hctz order lisinopril online requip online buy finpecia 1 mg australia ordering orlistat 120 mg online finpecia 1 mg without a prescription lisinopril 5 mg overnight delivery prednisone 20 mg purchase without prescription orlistat 120 mg no script overnight shipping on generic lisinopril 5 mg buy finasteride 1 mg online without a prescription order orlistat 120 mg online no prescription pharma life premarin 0.625 mg buy online no prescription buy seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg online requip 1 mg cheap online purchase cytotec 800 mg seroquel dangerous buy metformin online canada can i buy finasteride over the counter in canada order stromectol where can i buy prednisone online 1200 mg seroquel purchase maxalt no visa online without prescription 0.625mg premarin can i buy cytotec in mercury drug can i buy prednisolone in spain buy orlistat 120 mg online canada buy finasteride online uk order maxalt no prescription buy orlistat online canada order maxalt online no membership overnight shipping where can i buy prednisone over the counter buy prednisone 10mg online where can i buy prednisolone in the uk buy prednisone 5mg online buy prednisone without buy prednisone tablets online where to buy prednisolone 5mg for dogs can you buy prednisone over the counter in canada can i buy prednisone over the counter in mexico buy prednisone canada online order prednisone online canada how to order a prednisone taper buy prednisolone 5mg uk buy prednisone steroids can you buy prednisone in mexico buy prednisone uk where to buy prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension prednisolone 5mg buy online prednisolone acetate cheap buy prednisolone eye drops online where to order prednisone online where can i buy prednisolone uk order prednisone for pets order prednisone online buy prednisolone acetate eye drops where to buy prednisolone where can i buy prednisone order prednisolone online can you buy prednisolone online buy deltasone prednisone prednisone 10mg buy where to buy prednisone how to buy prednisone online prednisone for purchase can i buy prednisone online in uk buy prednisolone uk buy prednisolone in australia buy prednisone for cats where can i buy prednisolone tablets buy prednisolone 5mg for dogs buy prednisolone 25mg tablets cheap generic prednisone buy prednisolone in uk where to buy prednisolone for dogs buy prednisolone 1 mg buy prednisolone 5mg tablets buy prednisolone uk buy generic prednisone buy prednisone tablets can you buy prednisone over the counter buy prednisolone 5mg for dogs prednisone 10mg buy where to buy prednisolone in uk buy prednisone online now buy prednisolone eye drops online prednisone buy from uk how to order prednisone taper where can i buy prednisolone 5mg prednisolone 5mg to buy buy prednisolone 5mg online buy prednisone 10mg online prednisolone eye drops cheap where to buy prednisolone 5mg can you buy prednisone over the counter in canada can you order prednisone online where to buy cytotec in kenya purchase metformin pay pal without rx arimidex 1 mg tablets cheapest place to buy finasteride uk buy orlistat wholesele online order lisinopril no prescription buy cytotec malaysia maxalt over night where can you purchase finasteride buy prednisone for my dog how old do you have to be to buy cytotec atarax from canadian pharmacy buy maxalt without a perscription what happens if u overdose on seroquel where can i buy orlistat tablets can i buy cytotec at walmart lisinopril overdose in children buy abortion pills cytotec cytotec where can i buy it online buy cheap prednisone nice beauty buy abortion pills misoprostol cytotec buy cytotec 200 mcg order cytotec cheapest place to buy finasteride in uk finpecia 1 mg where to buy cytotec in mumbai buy cytotec in turkey buy cytotec quezon city cheap cytotec for sale buy benicar purchase finasteride finasteride purchase metformin visa without prescription purchase maxalt no scams where to buy cytotec in doha finasteride 1 mg without script online pharmacy cytotec 200 mcg no prescription buy seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg online uk can i get finpecia 1 mg without a prescription? premarin 0.625 mg without prescription buy premarin 0.625 mg online no prescription buy generic orlistat 120 mg online no prescription quick delivery overnight no prescription lisinopril 5 mg pay requip 1 mg nonprescription lisinopril 5 mg buy metformin 500 mg over the counter prednisone 20 mg generic online cheap generic requip 1 mg no prescription buy maxalt 5 mg online without prescription from canada where to buy cytotec in iloilo city buy maxalt no visa online without rx seroquel 200 mgs orlistat online no prescription get lisinopril buy metformin visa orlistat 120 mg buy lisinopril 5mg tablets seroquel online no prescription orlistat 60 mg for sale generic metformin online buy prednisone in the uk what is lisinopril 5 mg used for maxalt online consultation augmentin online n script purchase generic propecia metformin on line canada maxalt no perscription where to buy propecia forum allegra 120 mg bula how to order maxalt online without a prescription can you get high from requip buy metformin online no rx buy propecia in ireland buy cytotec online usa bactrim cheap lisinopril 10 mg for sale augmentin 457 buy metformin diet pills how to order propecia donde puedo comprar redustat orlistat buy prednisone 5mg online buy propecia boots buy prednisolone 40 mg augmentin syrup duo wholesale metformin cheap seroquel xl reviews premarin cheapest where can i buy original cytotec in the philippines cytotec pills for sale buy finasteride france seroquel reviews insomnia how to purchase prednisone cheapest place to get finasteride arimidex review where to buy finasteride (proscar finasteride) cytotec online forum where to go to get finasteride finasteride cheap canada maxalt cost cytotec for sale in qatar buy premarin cream use of seroquel for bipolar disorder premarin online canada buy merck finasteride can you come off seroquel how do i get arimidex cost metformin buy prednisone mastercard médicaments metformin et grossesse where to buy finpecia online buy prednisone online canada premarin vag cream price does arimidex get rid of acne seroquel xr discount coupon finasteride price at costco buy generic seroquel online maxalt best price cost finasteride ireland seroquel reviews for anxiety anafranil get high selling cytotec manila purchase prednisolone online where can i buy prednisone for dogs prednisone for dogs buy online uk purchase prednisone for dogs buy prednisone tablets buy prednisolone uk where to order prednisone online prednisolone purchase uk prednisolone 5mg buy online where can i buy prednisolone for my dog buy prednisolone 40 mg buy prednisolone in the uk can you buy prednisone over the counter how to buy prednisone online buy prednisone online overnight prednisolone for dogs buy online uk buy prednisone online now where can i buy prednisolone in the uk seroquel xr 150 mgs can u buy cytotec over the counter safest place to buy finasteride online metformin mail order where to buy cytotec in nigeria buy amoxicillin for dogs purchase cytotec (misoprostol) where to buy generic finasteride online where can i buy finasteride in ireland wholesale requip cheap orlistat without prescription best prices for 60mg. orlistat orlistat 60 mg canada premarin mg buy cheap requip can you order finasteride online seroquel 0.625mg premarin seroquel 50 mg high buy cytotec now finpecia uk maxalt without prescription cheap maxalt with no r x and free shipping revia cost get finasteride online uk how much does arimidex cost generic finasteride prescription where to buy cytotec in bahrain 4 corners pharmacy premarin effects of coming off seroquel how to buy finasteride in usa metformin review what is the street price of seroquel how to get a prescription for premarin buy finasteride and minoxidil premarin cream off label uses buy genuine finasteride online where can i buy cytotec in malaysia walmart price for finasteride side effects of coming off requip can you buy requip over the counter next day delivery on metformin saturday lisinopril 20mg online pharmacy how to order prednisone taper baclofen 20 mg street value orlistat tablets usa buy maxalt without a rx overnight shipping maxalt prescription from doctors online where i can buy cytotec in usa purchase cheap maxalt cod free fedex buy cytotec abu dhabi atarax on line where can i buy cytotec in kuwait lisinopril recall 2013 seroquel 100 mg high buy requip online no rx stromectol buy cheap where can i buy cytotec here in cebu where can we buy cytotec in cebu buy cytotec thailand is orlistat back in stock yet buy cheap finasteride online can you buy prednisone over the counter uk maxalt non perscription order lisinopril from canada premarin 0.625 mg tablet where to purchase valtrex online cheap maxalt without rx can you buy prednisolone online buy propranolol paypal metformin buy now finpecia free shipping buy propranolol for anxiety buy orlistat 60 mg with no prescription online purchase maxalt buy valtrex for cold sores where to buy cytotec in manila 2013 maxalt fedex shipping orlistat for sale seroquel mg dosage buy finasteride online mastercard buy generic amoxil online orlistat diet pill mexico synthroid cheap price can i buy metformin over the counter in spain metformin to buy uk buy prednisolone online australia can you buy metformin buy prednisolone in uk where can i buy prednisone for my dog can you buy prednisolone order prednisolone 5mg prednisone for dogs buy online uk buy prednisone online in uk can you buy metformin over the counter in dubai order lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide cheapest place to buy synthroid buy synthroid from canada need to buy lisinopril order lisinopril online from canada prednisone for purchase order prednisone online buy prednisolone 5mg tablets buy synthroid generic buy metformin 250 mg order prednisolone how to order metformin online buy metformin australia purchase prednisone for dogs premarin from india is it safe lisinopril rezept no rx arimidex with fedex seroquel tabletten buy maxalt in europe purchase premarin overnight lisinopril no prescription overnight lisinopril side effects prezzo requip buy metformin visa where can i buy cytotec over the counter fedex premarin without priscription where to buy generic maxalt online without a rx lisinopril drug purchase seroquel i want to buy premarin without a perscription buy cheap requip on line cytotec tablets 100 mg no prescription australia lisinopril online order how to buy premarin online without rx cheap generic lisinopril seroquel cheap cheap premarin by money order prednisone available at health department premarin without prescription medications purchase cheap lisinopril online buy online arimidex without rx buy premarin no prescription order no prescription premarin how to buy finasteride online without a prescription buy premarin no prescriptions order cytotec without rx order orlistat online no prescription purchase premarin paypal without prescription maxalt overnight delivery no r x buy arimidex where buy metformin no prescription low cost where to buy prednisone no prescription purchase premarin visa buy arimidex cheapest online indian pharmacy for prednisone or generic online pharmacy seroquel buy requip epharmacist purchase prednisolone tablets generic orlistat india seroquel 50 mgs can you buy metformin over the counter in dubai order proscar online uk how to buy prednisone from canada overnight maxalt c.o.d buy requip online without prescription is it safe to order finasteride online can you buy metformin over the counter in spain where to buy cytotec pills in south africa cheap cytotec philippines 600 mg seroquel too much buy finasteride 1mg online order finasteride overnight cheap arimidex overnight delivery fed ex how to order maxalt online without a rx buy cytotec india maxalt fedex shipping finasteride delivered overnight buy discount metformin on line order requip uk buy maxalt next day delivery buy cytotec without a percsription no prescription needed maxalt buy in seroquel uk buy cheap seroquel line where can you buy bactrim buy generic orlistat cheap cheap premarin cheap finasteride canada maxalt no prior script prednisolone for dogs to buy cheapest place to buy proscar buy prednisone for dogs buy generic finasteride online cheap buy requip mastercard prednisolone where can i buy it can i buy prednisone at walmart prednisolone 5mg buy online buy veterinary prednisone buy prednisone for humans where can i buy prednisolone uk can you buy prednisolone over the counter buy prednisone online australia where can i buy prednisolone tablets buy prednisone 20mg buy prednisolone for dogs buy prednisolone how to buy prednisone for dogs can i buy prednisone in mexico best place to buy prednisone buy prednisone online uk prednisone purchase canada buy cheap prednisone can you buy prednisone online buy prednisolone 5mg online prednisolone for dogs to buy uk buy apo prednisone buy prednisone mexico prednisolone tablets to buy buy prednisolone 5mg for dogs in uk how to buy lisinopril online order prednisone for pets buy metformin mexico buy prednisone 1 mg can i buy metformin over the counter in uk buy generic metformin buy metformin paypal where to buy lisinopril hctz how to buy metformin in singapore where can i buy prednisolone uk where to buy prednisone steroid where can i buy synthroid where to buy prednisolone eye drops metformin mail order where to purchase synthroid how to order synthroid can you buy prednisolone over the counter uk where can i purchase prednisone buy brand name synthroid online cheapest price for metformin buy metformin 500 buy stromectol for humans buy prednisone dogs buy synthroid 112 mcg requip for sale how can i order valtrex online purchase atarax online order valtrex uk buy prednisolone suppositories proscar 5 mg cheap no prescriptions needed for maxalt where to buy metformin weight loss purchase online maxalt without prescription buy arimidex no prescription lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide buy online where can i buy finasteride online maxalt on line no prescription purchase finpecia purchase cheap online requip how to order maxalt online without prescription premarin generic equivalent purchase amoxil online premarin 0.625 mg side effects maxalt online consultation where could i buy cytotec can i buy finasteride over the counter uk where can i buy cytotec pills in south africa buy cheapest finasteride online buy finasteride lloyds pharmacy best price on arimidex hat happened to orlistat online metformin buy online pharmacy metformin premarin 2.5 mg buy metformin amex buy no perscription maxalt purchase maxalt online no membership overnight shipping buy genuine metformin cytotec where to buy quickly buy herbal metformin buy prednisone australia benicar 5mg without prescription maxalt overnight no consult orlistat from canada arimidex 1 mg seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg no prescription needed buy discounted lisinopril 5 mg online india lisinopril 5 mg buy maxalt 5 mg without a prescription lisinopril 5 mg no rx cytotec 200 mcg online order canadian pharmacy cytotec 200 mcg maxalt 5 mg no rx prednisone 20 mg online without a prescription cytotec 200 mcg generic no prescription generic finasteride 1 mg online no prescription lisinopril 5 mg generic sale prednisone 20 mg with out a prescription cytotec 200 mcg online sale without prescription maxalt 5 mg online no prescription overnight no prescription seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg orlistat full strength seroquel 300 mg price order metformin online lamisil cheap generic augmentin seroquel xr 400 mgs can i buy metformin in uk can you buy fluoxetine over the counter in uk lamisil 250 mg dosage buy seroquel buy motilium new zealand priligy sales in singapore orlistat 120 mgs order avodart uk augmentin 625 mg buy online where to buy avodart online can you buy motilium over counter in ireland where can i buy bactrim where to buy metformin 500 mg orlistat us priligy_dapoxetin_kaufen order metformin canada buy seroquel online with visa buy topamax how to order metformin online buy metformin buy nizoral 700 mg seroquel side effects topamax 100mg buy avodart 2.5 where to buy bactrim ds online viacom orlistat diet pill is orlistat taken off market order orlistat orlistat online cheapest quick online orlistat cheap orlistat 120mg how to order orlistat orlistat pris buy orlistat usa no prescription orlistat online no prescription xenical 120 mg orlistat reviews buy orlistat in mexico buy alli orlistat online us pharmacy orlistat purchase orlistat generic uk orlistat 120 mg price order maxalt no visa arimidex for low testosterone us maxalt fedex buy prescription maxalt online where to buy cytotec 2013 where can i buy original cytotec in the philippines where to buy cytotec abortion pills metformin sale buy prednisone cheap order maxalt without rx from us pharmacy baclofen 10 mg street value ebay orlistat alli orlistat online where to buy prednisone for dogs canadian orlistat manufacturers can i buy cytotec at walgreens cheap finasteride australia buy cytotec in malaysia metformin without doctor prescription atarax over the counter equivalent buy orlistat nyc seroquel no prescription pharmacy metformin by mail metformin canada purchase maxalt without a prescription overnight shipping arimidex no prescrption cheap maxalt cod next day delivery where can i buy prednisolone tablets for dogs in the uk drugs similar to lisinopril metformin best buy maxalt online uk order lisinopril no prescription what does requip cost seroquel 50 mg street value cheap finpecia orlistat without perscription uk can i buy cytotec in mercury drug seroquel quetiapine 100 mg buy atarax cheap hat happened to orlistat orlistat lesofat side effects atarax 25 mg for anxiety buy cheap generic finasteride cheap cytotec pills cheap maxalt by money order buy premarin 0.625 mg 200mcg getting premarin 0.625 mg without doctor orlistat 120 mg online without a prescription buy lisinopril 5 mg online without prescription maxalt 5 mg ordered without a perscription prednisone 20 mg without a prescription order metformin 500 mg ordering maxalt 5 mg online without a precription ordering premarin 0.625 mg online without a precription prednisone 20 mg prescription online next day delivery metformin 500 mg online purchase premarin 0.625 mg no prescription required order cytotec 200 mcg online order seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg without rx how to get lisinopril 5 mg online no prescription in 100 days wholesale requip 1 mg canadian pharmacy no prescription maxalt 5 mg can i get finasteride 1 mg without rx buy generic metformin 500 mg no prescription cytotec 200 mcg purchase without prescription buy discounted orlistat 120 mg online where can i buy premarin 0.625 mg cheap prednisone 20 mg online no prescription finpecia 1 mg order on line finpecia 1 mg purchase overnight delivery premarin 0.625 mg 200mcg pay finasteride 1 mg lisinopril 5 mg online no prescription and overnight metformin 500 mg online no prescription and overnight generic requip 1 mg online no prescription buy metformin 500 mg next day delivery order finasteride uk where can i buy finasteride in the uk can you buy prednisone over the counter for dogs metformin overdose alli orlistat can you snort baclofen 10 mg maxalt shipped overnight no prescription purchase generic metformin online baclofen 10 mg tablet buy finasteride cream buy prednisone 1 mg no rx maxalt with fedex prednisone to buy uk buy metformin with amex 700 mg seroquel side effects buy finasteride 1mg tablets overnight maxalt without a perscription seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg for sale maxalt 5 mg online no prescriptions required from the us premarin 0.625 mg for sale usa buy cytotec 200 mcg no prescription generic requip 1 mg canada orlistat 120 mg requip 1 mg with no prescription generic 100mcg metformin 500 mg online buy finpecia 1 mg over the counter where can i buy seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg can i get finasteride 1 mg without rx finpecia 1 mg cost prednisone 20 mg order on line buy finasteride 1 mg online without prescription requip 1 mg without a perscription buy real finasteride buy finasteride online paypal seroquel 25 mg side effects buy prednisone dose pack lowest price for premarin requip fedex shipping where i can buy cytotec online maxalt without a prescription canadian cheap orlistat buy prednisolone 5mg online mail order lisinopril where can i buy finasteride in india pharmacy requip buy stromectol ivermectin buy cytotec 200mg should i buy generic finasteride orlistat alli buy buy cytotec abortion online buy proscar india where to buy cytotec in oman buy generic prednisone online orlistat canada where to buy propranolol online buy cytotec in egypt finasteride over night buy lisinopril toronto buy cheap premarin online free consult order premarin pay pal online without rx purchase arimidex overnight online metformin purchase cheap prednisone premarin apotheke purchase finasteride no prescription cheap purchase cheap seroquel online 5 mg lisinopril how to order arimidex online without a prescription buy generic arimidex where can i buy some cytotec online only using cash or money orders cheap arimidex no rx buy lisinopril 30 mg 700 mg seroquels where to buy orlistat wholesale buy prednisolone steroid how to get perscription of maxalt acheter orlistat generic maxalt tablets no script maxalt requip buy online in stock seroquel mg dosage premarin 0.625 mg cream purchase cytotec online buy metformin in uk seroquel wholesale finpecia generic lisinopril prescription buy cheap metformin line prescription maxalt online ordering premarin without a script seroquel overdose purchase cheap prescription maxalt finasteride online no prescription mail order finasteride maxalt online no perscription overnight buy requip legally maxalt order online no membership overnight where can i buy some orlistat online only using cash or money orders premarin no doctors prescription buy metformin without a rx buy premarin online cheap maxalt with no rx and free shipping arimidexbuy on line where to buy proscar forum buy finasteride in india can you buy finasteride in mexico buy brand valtrex online maxalt cod online orders where is the best place to buy generic finasteride buy finasteride from canada can you order valtrex online seroquel 200 mg street price order maxalt free next day airmaxalt on line orlistat 60mg no prescription requip buy requip now purchase generic antabuse online order buy celebrex online buy baclofen without a credit card buy antabuse in the uk uses for diflucan online prescription compazine buy cheap fluconazole no prescription buy cytotec online no prescription online consultation for prednisone order compazine buy generic glucophage online purchase cheap prescription proscar where to buy proscar no prescription no fees lioresal without a prescription or doctor purchasing fincar order prednisone without a rx overnight shipping maxalt u.p.s shipping cod fluconazole prescription overnight lioresal without a prescription purchasing prednisone with overnight delivery online celebrex purchase buy lioresal cost buy maxalt no prescription buy priligy 10 mg can i buy cytotec online cheap prednisone no rx priligy in canada buy glucophage fed ex antabuse prescription proscar shipped cash on buy cheap online pharmacy robaxin order rx free priligy buy real cytotec prednisone on line compazine prices buy maxalt amex online without rx baclofen 1000 mg where to buy prednisone no prescription no fees purchase lioresal without a rx online no prescripton prednisone order proscar on line cheap bactrim online where can i buy metformin tablets seroquel 25 mg price donde puedo comprar redustat orlistat where to buy proscar in australia premarin 0.3 mg buy prednisolone online uk buy cytotec online with mastercard 1000 mg seroquel online prescriptions maxalt buy finasteride in malaysia corlistat in australia buy maxalt online cod buy liquid prednisone buy stromectol online buy cytotec dubai where can i get requip 1 mg can i get orlistat 120 mg without rx how to get metformin 500 mg generic seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg without prescription order finasteride 1 mg online consultation buy finpecia 1 mg online 200 mcg no prescription seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg no prescription needed 200mcg finasteride 1 mg buy online no prescription is it legal to buy metformin 500 mg online cheap cytotec 200 mcg without a prescription orlistat 120 mg without prescription do you need a prescription for maxalt 5 mg in mexico no prescription cytotec 200 mcg lisinopril 5 mg buy online without rx lisinopril 5 mg in canada buy metformin for pcos online buy finasteride ireland seroquel xr 50 mg for anxiety order propranolol online uk buy bactrim requip 2 mg buy requip australia how to buy cytotec in quiapo buy requip amex seroquel et zopiclone buy prednisone 20mg tablets how to get maxalt perscription where is the best place to buy finasteride prednisolone where can i buy it where to buy stromectol online where to buy prednisolone for dogs buy metformin online without buy prednisone for cats buy metformin for pcos uk order stromectol mastercard buy prednisolone tablets for cats buy prednisone from canada want to buy prednisone buy prednisone uk where to buy prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension can i buy lisinopril online buy prednisone 20 mg buy prednisolone 5mg for dogs in uk is it safe to buy synthroid online buy cheap prednisone prednisone 20 mg purchase buy generic prednisone buy metformin in usa buy prednisolone acetate eye drops buy metformin er buy prednisone cheap buy prednisone 5 mg buy stromectol for humans buy metformin hcl 500 mg buy finasteride 84 finasteride order europe buy metformin cheap buy genuine finasteride online order prednisolone buy lisinopril 5mg canada requip order valtrex from canada can you buy amoxicillin 500mg where can i buy cytotec in ghana requip for sale where to buy cytotec in cebu where to buy finasteride in singapore buy generic finasteride online cheap finasteride sales uk finasteride finasteride online seroquel xr 400mg cost best price finasteride uk pil cytotec online how long to get pregnant on metformin seroquel xr reviews can you buy cytotec over the counter in south africa finasteride results reviews cheap finasteride nz arimidex prescription orlistat price in pakistan is it legal to buy cytotec online amsa fast orlistat como se toma maxalt mail order prescription assistance for premarin patient reviews on seroquel xr purchase metformin without a prescription overnight shipping no prescriptions needed for maxalt buy lisinopril overnight how to buy requip without a prescription cheap prices on cytotec cheap purchase premarin buy arimidex shipped cod buy lisinopril without doctor buy requip australia order finasteride without rx needed buy line requip buy seroquel on line without a rx overnight premarin c.o.d generic orlistat without a precsriptions maxalt overnight fed ex no prescription arimidex cash on delivery overnight shipping on generic orlistat buy metformin cheap without prescription seroquel citrate purchase finasteride no prescription cheap prednisone online no prescription buy seroquel online without prescription can i get prednisone without rx prednisone oral tablet no prescription discount premarin buy online in stock orlistat no prescription buy seroquel on line amex buy metformin in mo generic finpecia 1 mg without a precsriptions seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg without a prescription prednisone 20 mg buy no prescription order finpecia 1 mg online overnight shipping metformin 500 mg without prescription online pharmacy finasteride 1 mg no prescription mail order prednisone 20 mg get orlistat 120 mg without prescription were to buy premarin 0.625 mg purchace prednisone 20 mg online seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg no rx generic 100mcg metformin 500 mg online generic prednisone 20 mg without a precsriptions finasteride 1 mg purchase without prescription non prescription metformin 500 mg maxalt 5 mg without prescription metformin 500 mg purchase without perscripotion buy prednisone 20 mg 200mcg buy online finpecia 1 mg buy lisinopril 5 mg over the counter is it legal to buy finasteride 1 mg online metformin 500 mg no rx how to buy prednisone 20 mg without a prescription overnight no prescription finpecia 1 mg requip 1 mg online without a prescription order metformin 500 mg online overnight shipping order finasteride 1 mg mastercard cheapest premarin 0.625 mg buy online seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg order seroquel online buy maxalt online with next day shipping maxalt without a presciption buy maxalt overnight shipping no prescription cytotec order finasteride cash on delivery want to buy metformin in usa buy cheap metformin online cytotec buy online without rx buy maxalt cod next day delivery buy finpecia online prescription arimidex tabletten how to buy orlistat without a prescription order arimidex usa cod metformin overnight purchase online prescription maxalt without buy lisinopril online from canada buy arimidex doctor prescription buy arimidex usa buy cheap requip under without rx cheapest place to buy requip order arimidex online seroquel online prescription buy cheapest requipbuy no prior prescription requip buy seroquel cash on delivery buy lisinopril without doctor buy finasteride amex online seroquel usa buy next day seroquel buy valacyclovir and requip premarin prices buy original finasteride online buy finasteride amazon arimidex for sale cheap buy orlistat without prescription wholesale alli orlistat from india lisinopril 10mg tablets prices premarin can you get high on requip finpecia without perscription buy metformin in united states online buy maxalt online overnight lisinopril 20 mgs buy cheapest metformin and metformin buy metformin in the uk free premarin requip overnight how to buy arimidex without a prescription c.o.d synthroid finpecia over the counter premarin online consultant seroquel without prescription premarin buy fedex prednisone no prescription overnight delivery purchase arimidex on line no rx cheap synthroid without a prescription buy cod arimidex buy prednisone without a percsription generic requip uk where can i order metformin maxalt online order saturday delivery cheap proscar australia seroquel xr 300 mg tablet valtrex for purchase buy maxalt without rx needed how to buy generic valtrex where to buy cytotec in oman buy amoxicillin walgreens canada orlistat otc order maxalt online next day delivery where to buy cytotec in doha buy metformin for pcos can you buy amoxicillin at cvs can i buy prednisone at walmart buy seroquel pay cod no script synthroid online purchase metformin generic prednisone without a precsriptions purchase arimidex pay pal without rx buy generic finpecia uk buy orlistat oral finpecia over the counter buy lisinopril money buy prednisone online no prescription and overnight purchase finasteride online with overnight delivery buy finpecia uk comprare seroquel generico purchase finasteride online without prescription arimidex mexico comprar seroquel generico where can i buy prednisone buy requip toronto buy finasteride without buy lisinopril from india arimidex no prior script buy propecia (finpecia) online orlistat 120 mg for sale usa canadian finasteride buy seroquel pills buy arimidex 1mg purchase online prescription premarin purchase synthroid online no membership overnight shipping requip buy online finasteride ordering without dr maxalt non prescription for next day delivery cytotec no prescription overnight delivery maxalt no doctors consult prednisone order comprare premarin generico buy generic requip online buy online cytotec 100 mg maxalt online prescriptions with no membership buying premarin online purchase maxalt without prescription needed buy metformin with amex no rx needed for purchasing maxalt lisinopril to buy how to order premarin online without prescription metformin citrate finasteride 5 mg order online how to order clomid and metformin buy orlistat 120mg online how to purchase finasteride buy prednisone buy requip no rx order bactrim ds online do you need a prescription to buy metformin shere to buy orlistat over the counter venda sale buy mifepristone cytotec ru486 misoprostol canadian prescriptions maxalt maxalt online without a perscription buy no perscription maxalt maxalt without presciption buy propranolol online canada buy cytotec online overnight how to order finasteride maxalt tablets price finasteride online india premarin 1.25 mg tablets price cytotec prescription example where to buy cytotec in bicol buy generic maxalt online where did i buy cytotec is metformin a prescription drug get finasteride prescription online purchase finasteride requip for rls reviews is finasteride a prescription drug cheap metformin xr weight loss cytotec costo ecuador buy revia naltrexone buy finpecia online india buy no online rx rizatriptan buy 1 mg requip where to buy cytotec no prescription d3wwqa lisinopril overdose buy requip with a mastercard finasteride without a prescription shipped overnight express finasteride shipped by cash on delivery premarin cod online orders buy 5 mg lisinopril where to buy orlistat no prescription order finpecia online no prescription buy lisinopril without doctor buy arimidex without a perscription overnight shipping on generic cytotec generic finasteride no prescription maxalt in mexico without a perscription order arimidex online next day delivery buying requip buy lisinopril now online overnight shipping finasteride no prescription arimidex with fedex purchase arimidex usa cod where to buy cytotec in iloilo city overnight maxalt without a rx buy lisinopril hctz 20 12.5 mg where can i buy prednisone for my cat can i buy metformin over the counter in spain buy maxalt no visa online without prescription c.o.d maxalt finpecia generic lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide buy online maxalt online consultant seroquel 25 mg side effects generic orlistat 60 mg buy generic bactrim ds order ampicillin 125 mg im q4h buy maxalt daily use orlistat froom china order cytotec online in philippines requip order online buy amoxil 500 mg online buy cheap valtrex buy no perscription maxalt where can i buy finasteride in the philippines i want to order maxalt without a perscription cheap proscar australia do you need a prescription to buy metformin where to buy generic finasteride uk purchase cytotec (misoprostol) how to order maxalt online without prescription seroquel xr 400 mg order bactrim best place to buy generic finasteride online where can i buy cytotec in uae buy prednisolone online where to order finasteride online buy liquid amoxicillin for dogs online purchase maxalt comprar requip generico buy cytotec online uk buy prednisone canada online buy maxalt next day delivery buy proscar india cheap bactrim ds where to buy cytotec in cagayan de oro city where to buy finpecia 1 mg metformin 500 mg available at health department get lisinopril 5 mg without prescription overnight no prescription orlistat 120 mg premarin 0.625 mg over the counter generic cytotec 200 mcg canada can i get requip 1 mg without a prescription? buy requip 1 mg online made in america cytotec 200 mcg precio requip 1 mg cheap online canadian pharmacy buy cytotec 200 mcg australia no prescription orlistat 120 mg with out a prescription maxalt 5 mg from mexico buy finasteride 1 mg online with no prescription non prescription cheap finasteride buy orlistat without rx purchase premarin visa purchase no perscription arimidex order generic seroquel metformin price order rx free arimidex purchase arimidex no visa online without prescription buy metformin where order requip online buy arimidex no visa without rx purchase arimidex usa cod buy discount lisinopril online purchase arimidex online buy metformin fed ex seroquel precio buy no prescription finasteride where to buy requip without a prescription purchase cheap premarin online buy pharmacy metformin waterview premarin without prescription overnight shipping cheap generic premarin what does seroquel look like buy propecia finpecia australia buy cheap seroquel no prescription purchase cheap seroquel finasteride online no prescription overnight buy requip now buy seroquel without a rx buy prednisone over the counter uk medication cytotec misoprostol buy online buy prednisone cheap without perscription cheapest prednisone 20 mg where can i buy finasteride in bangalore buy cytotec online australia buy finasteride online europe do i need a prescription to buy finasteride buy finasteride online review buy requip without a perscription legit site to buy finasteride how to get finasteride cheap where can i purchase maxalt without a prescription maxalt overnight no script mastercard accepted where to buy bactrim buy propranolol buy finasteride online forum were to buy metformin purchase requip pay pal without rx no perscription maxalt where to purchase lisinopril where to buy proscar uk i want a maxalt prescription buy propranolol online order finasteride online buy cytotec china where can i buy cytotec in bacolod seroquel xr 400 mg buy proscar hong kong orlistat shortage uk buy requip without a prescription online where can i buy atarax in uk orlistat xenical uk orlistat 120 mg information where to buy cytotec in pampanga purchase premarin no visa without prescription maxalt without prescription shipped overnight express prednisolone tablets buy online buy amoxicillin 250 mg online uk nice beauty buy abortion pills misoprostol cytotec where can i buy cytotec buy maxalt online no perscription where to buy proscar in malaysia premarin 0.3 mg tablets can you buy amoxicillin 500mg buy proscar 5 mg online buy valtrex cheap buy atarax in uk where to buy bactrim online order maxalt on line buy maxalt order no prescription premarin buy finasteride free consultation seroquel citrate comprar seroquel generico maxalt non rx fedex overnight free buy brand metformin cheap finasteride no script premarin online uk metformin buy online buy amoxicillin 500mg canada where can i buy bactrim ds premarin effects finpecia dose for hair loss purchase maxalt amex online without rx buy 850 mg metformin no prescription generic cytotec can i buy cytotec over the counter in south africa cytotec order overnight maxalt 5 mg generic online metformin 500 mg purchase without perscripotion canada lisinopril 5 mg requip 1 mg express online where can i buy metformin 500 mg buying maxalt 5 mg online without prescription generic cytotec 200 mcg no prescription maxalt 5 mg buy cheap orlistat 120 mg cheap on online how to order seroquel 200 100 50 300 mg how to order finpecia 1 mg buy cytotec 200 mcg oral cytotec 200 mcg online cheap premarin 0.625 mg order online buy orlistat 120 mg online 200 mcg no prescription metformin 500 mg buy cheap orlistat 120 mg prescription cost where can i buy cytotec in davao overnight no prescription cytotec where to buy cytotec in cebu cytotec 100 mg without prescription cheap cytotec online buy cytotec australia cytotec on line buy cytotec in singapore where can i buy cytotec in bacolod can i buy cytotec in boots buy prednisone online canada purchase prednisolone buy prednisone 40mg order prednisone online canada can i buy prednisone over the counter in spain buy prednisone with no prescription prednisone order on line where can i buy prednisolone 5mg order prednisone for pets prednisone sale no prescription buy prednisone online australia prednisolone 5mg buy online order prednisone online overnight shipping can you buy prednisone in spain cheap online pharmacy for prednisone buy prednisone uk how to buy prednisone for dogs prednisone generic can i buy prednisone online in uk uk medication prednisone prednisone buy online purchase prednisone non prescription prednisone prednisone online no prescriptions required from the us prednisolone for dogs to buy uk buy prednisolone tablets buy prednisone 20mg tablets prescribing prednisone tablets australia low price rx online website prednisone where to buy prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension prednisone overnight without prescription cheap prednisone online no prescription buy prednisone 1mg purchase prednisolone prednisolone backorder buy prednisone 10mg online buy prednisone oral prednisone no prescription required buy prednisone online now buy prednisolone tablets uk buy generic prednisone how to order prednisone where to purchase prednisone oral cheap prednisolone 5mg to buy uk cheap online pharmacy for prednisone order prednisone no prescription where to purchase prednisone were to buy prednisone buy prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension buy liquid prednisone prednisone cheap online order prednisone prednisone no rx in us buy prednisone in the uk buy generic prednisone without perscription online pharmacy prednisone no prescription buy prednisone 40mg buy prednisolone 40 mg where i can buy cytotec in manila where to buy cytotec over the counter buy cytotec canada buy cheap cytotec where to buy original cytotec how to buy cytotec in italy buy cytotec thailand where to buy cytotec in batangas city where can i buy genuine cytotec where to buy cytotec in davao buy cytotec australia buy cytotec amazon where can i buy cytotec in bulacan where to buy cytotec how to buy cytotec in dubai buy and sell cytotec where to buy cytotec in dumaguete where can you buy cytotec where to buy cytotec in cebu city buy cytotec for abortion were to buy cytotec where can i buy cytotec philippines buy real cytotec manila where can i buy original cytotec in quiapo buy cytotec in usa where to buy genuine cytotec in cebu where can i buy cytotec in singapore where to buy cytotec in the philippines wholesale premarin cheap buy metformin online us pharmacy cheap generic cytotec no prescription lisinopril to buy purchase arimidex money purchase order cytotec mastercard buy propecia generic finpecia order arimidex uk finasteride buy fedex online seroquel purchase buy cheap requip online free consult maxalt no physicisn consult prednisone online no prescription buy arimidex buy xenical cheap without perscription buy maxalt overnight delivery
Benedict XVI and Communion in the Hand: Put Aside Your Illusions

Benedict XVI and Communion in the Hand: Put Aside Your Illusions

"Not opposed in principle."

EVER SINCE the post-Vatican II revolution began, the liturgical change that faithful Catholics regarded as most horrifying was communion in the hand. It overthrew everything — everything — we had been taught to believe about the ineffable holiness of the Real Presence and the sacred character of the priesthood.

The 16th-century Protestant heretics who abolished communion on the tongue and introduced communion in the hand were well aware of the doctrines the old practice represented, and changed the mode of receiving communion precisely in order to overthrow these teachings.

So too, during and after Vatican II. The modernist heretics great and small (and I knew many in the latter category) who promoted errors such as transfinalization, transignification, a “transient” presence of Christ in the Eucharist, assembly theology or a “lay” priesthood inevitably also advocated communion in the hand. Denying Catholic dogmas on the Real Presence and the priesthood went together with the new ritual practice — which said “Nothing special here; just plain old bread.”

Many who now advocate more traditional liturgical practices have looked upon Benedict XVI as a sympathetic ally who seeks to restore tradition in Catholic worship. Hence, the permission given for the old Mass, the reappearance of old-style vestments at St. Peter’s, the encouragement given to worthy sacred music, etc.

Since the reception of communion on the tongue logically would seem to be part of this package, and since Benedict XVI was rumored to be opposed to communion in the hand, many were shocked to see pictures of him personally distributing communion in the hand, most recently, to the Queen of Spain.

Various explanations were offered in the pro-Benedict traditionalist camp: the poor pope had been pressured into the practice, he did not want to cause scandal (!) by refusing someone communion, pastoral prudence motivated him, etc., etc. Few, it seems, wanted to put aside the image of Benedict as the Great-but-Patient-Restorer-of-Catholic-Liturgical-Tradition

One need speculate no longer about possible explanations. In an interview just published as a book (Light of the World), Benedict XVI says:

I am not opposed in principle to Communion in the hand; I have both administered and received Communion in this way myself.

So there we have it in Benedict’s own words: he  believes that there is nothing wrong in itself with communion in the hand.

But if there is no principle to oppose, why the widely-publicized business of communicants in St. Peter’s being made to kneel and receive on the tongue?

The idea behind my current practice of having people kneel to receive Communion on the tongue was to send a signal and to underscore the Real Presence with an exclamation point. One important reason is that there is a great danger of superficiality precisely in the kinds of Mass events we hold at Saint Peter’s, both in the Basilica and in the Square. I have heard of people who, after receiving Communion, stick the Host in their wallet to take home as a kind of souvenir.

The return to the traditional practice was, in other words, merely a practical expediency to forestall the incidental, by-the-way, regrettable problems of superficiality and souvenir hunting.

In this context, where people think that everyone is just automatically supposed to receive Communion — everyone else is going up, so I will, too—I wanted to send a clear signal. I wanted it to be clear:  Something quite special is going on here! He is here, the  One before whom we fall on our knees! Pay attention!

This is not just some social ritual in which we can take part if we want to.

A question of "context."

In the foregoing passage and those which preceded it, we find more of the convolution so typical of modernist theological discourse. A few bones are thrown towards Catholics who hunger for tradition and the old dogmas (thus: “underscoring the Real Presence,” “something special,” “not just some social ritual”), while the larger and more fundamental issue at stake is rendered completely relative (“in this context,” “danger” of superficiality).

We have seen this before in Ratztinger/Benedict’s pronouncements on the liturgy. He comes out in favor of some traditional practice: the old Mass, facing “east” for the Eucharistic prayer, more Latin, traditional vestments, high-quality music, etc. Beleaguered conservatives and traditionalists rejoice: the restoration has begun!

But upon closer examination, one quickly discovers that Ratzinger/Benedict’s starting point for arriving at these conclusions is often located in another theological universe: e.g., attractive “sacrality,” culture, sensibilities, the Teilhardian cosmos, richness. (See Work of Human Hands, 5–6,  170–72)

This should come as no surprise, because the young Josef Ratzinger was himself formed in the mid-20th century modernist theological universe that rejected the methods and principles of Thomist (i.e. Catholic) theology.

So the traditional tone of Benedict’s practical conclusions should not divert us from the poisonous principles behind them. The modernist George Tyrrell (1861–1909), after all, was likewise a great fan of the Latin High Mass, “with all its suggestion of mystery, faith and reverence.” (Through Scylla and Charybdis, 34)

Courtesy of Benedict XVI, conservatives and advocates of officially-sanctioned celebrations of the old Mass are thus left without a fixed theological principle upon which to hang their opposition to communion in the hand. It’s all “context” now — the Holy Father says so!

As for sending what Benedict called “a clear signal,” ever since the advent of the Protestant and Modernist heresies on the nature of the Eucharist, the signal communion in the hand has sent is very clear indeed: I repudiate the dogma of transubstantiation.

So too, the signal Benedict XVI’s recent statement should send to conservatives: It is time to put aside your illusions.

This entry was posted in 01 Old Mass or New Mass, 13 Communion Rite, WHH Chapter Topics. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

6 Comments

  1. Timothy
    Posted November 23, 2010 at 1:40 pm | Permalink

    Father Cekada:

    Given this post, could you comment on the ancient practice of communion in the hand? I have heard that St. Cyril of Jerusalem, in his catechetical lectures makes reference to this practice in his day. I have been told that both in the west, and in the east (and even in among the Copts) communion became a direct-to-tongue practice for practical purposes to prevent abuse (along with mixing both elements into the chalice in the east, though this was never followed among the Copts, and restricting communion to the laity to sub una specie).

    Because of this precedent, would this not be the line of reasoning that people would follow who advocate communion in the hand in our times? Please comment on the ancient precedent and its relation to your post. Thank you.

  2. Posted November 23, 2010 at 8:14 pm | Permalink

    I briefly discuss the historical aspect of the question in Work of Human Hands, 369–70. Here is the pertinent passage:

    1. History. When communion in the hand was introduced after Vatican II, those who promoted it tried to convey the general impression that it represented the restoration of a practice once universally followed by the ancient Church. The argument, often left unstated, was, how could one possibly object to an early Christian practice as disrespectful or somehow unorthodox?

    The key text employed to this end was a passage from the fourth century Mystagogic Catecheses (instructions in the faith for new converts) attributed to Cyril of Jerusalem, but in fact probably not written by him:

    “When you approach, do not go stretching out your open hands or having your fingers spread out, but make the left hand into a throne for the right hand which shall receive the King, and then cup your open hand and take the Body of Christ, reciting the Amen… ”

    Jungmann cites other texts from this period and somewhat later (mainly Eastern) that seem to corroborate the practice as described, and Archdale King cites texts from Tertullian (+225), St. Cyprian (+258) and St. Augustine (+430).

    Father P.M. Gy, however, observes that communion was always given in the mouth to the sick, and up until the twelfth century, also to babies. Moreover, in antiquity elements of imperial court ceremonial also influenced the liturgy, which then incorporated different practices for receiving communion in a hand covered with a veil. As regards the latter practice in the West, Jungmann records that Caesarius of Arles (+543) and the Synod of Auxerre (578 or 585) both mention the requirement that women receive communion only with a hand covered with a veil.

    So, despite the endlessly recycled text attributed to Cyril, it is by no means certain that the exact method it seems to describe — a host placed into the communicant’s bare palm — was the same for all communicants or obtained everywhere.

    Growing devotion to the Blessed Sacrament, as well as a deepening respect for the priesthood, eventually led to the practice of the priest placing the host directly into communicant’s mouth. The host seems to have been received at Rome this way about the time of St. Gregory the Great (590–604), and according to Archdale King, communion in the hand was condemned by a synod held at Rouen under Clovis II in about 650 AD.

    Liturgical scholars have been unable to fix an exact date for when communion on the tongue became the universal practice. Gy maintains that it was hastened in part by the universal adoption in Carolingian times (eighth century) of the ceremony for the consecration of priest’s hands at ordination.

    This would be consistent with the explanation that St. Thomas gives for communion in the mouth. Out of reverence for this sacrament, nothing touches it but what is consecrated, hence the corporal and the chalice are consecrated, and likewise the priest’s hand for touching this sacrament.

    ———————

    As may be seen from the foregoing, it is often very difficult to resolve with certitude questions about details of ritual practices in the the Church’s earlier days.

    Those who favored introducing communion in the hand after Vatican II were in fact modernists who sought to destroy traditional Catholic teaching on transubstantiation, the priesthood and the nature of the Mass, and who viewed communion in the hand as a ritual means to achieve this end. The popular heresies at that time were transignification (the “meaning” of the bread changes) and transfinalization (the “purpose” of the bread changes). The practice of communion in the hand arose in the Low Countries (hotbeds of these modernist heresies during Vatican II) and quickly spread to “progressive” circles throughout the world.

    Naturally, the innovators appealed to “antiquity” as their precedent. But the affection of heretics for antiquity is limited to those practices they can twist to serve their new doctrines; whatever in antiquity contradicts their new doctrines is passed over in silence or “hidden from the eyes of the crowd,” as Dom Guéranger said.

    Hence, one heard no calls from the communion in the hand advocates in the 1960s for the “restoration” of other early Christian ritual practices such as public penance for sins confessed, all-night vigils, separation by sexes during Mass, prohibitions against women functioning as liturgical ministers, and veiling for women who assist at Mass. These did not fit in with the modernist program.

    The appeal to “antiquity,” therefore, must be regarded as camouflage for the underlying (heretical) theological agenda.

    While the reception of communion in the hand in the early Church — if, when, where and how it may have been practiced — would not have had an unorthodox theological connotation, the heresies of the 16th-century Protestants and the 20th-century modernists have certainly given it one.

  3. Fr. Kudriavtsev
    Posted November 24, 2010 at 4:56 pm | Permalink

    Dear Father Cekada,

    Thank you very much for this post. Being a Greek Catholic Byzantine Rite priest I can say that in the Divine Liturgies of St. Jacob, St. Basil the Great, St. John the Chrysostom and St. Gregory the Great a priest gives the Communion on the tongue always. God bless you.

  4. Timothy
    Posted November 24, 2010 at 5:54 pm | Permalink

    Thank you for your lengthy response, Father Cekada. I understand the basic crux of the argument, and that the evidence is unclear in any case whether or not one is in favor. But the problem that you point out of course, is that mining something from “antiquity” however obscure and making it into something “more orthodox” is essentially a Protestant sham, unfortunately. Even from a pastoral perspective, it would seem that the standardization of the Tridentine Mass and the bull which ratified it (and threatened anyone who changed it!) did so to prevent against the heresies at work through the Protestant reformers.

    Perhaps the reason communion in the hand might have been practiced at one time in one place was because these heresies were not threatening the Church and things were more secretive.

    However, since we are living in a post-Reformation (and post-Christian) world, the bewilderment of Ottaviani on this point seems well placed: why exactly does one think that the context in which Pope St. Pius V made his bull is no longer applicable? If anything, it’s even more relevant today because the Reformation has begun to bear its true fruit in abundance: secularism. Father forgive them…

  5. Posted November 24, 2010 at 7:40 pm | Permalink

    And indeed that is the crux of the problem. While communion in the hand in ancient times would not have carried any heretical baggage, it does now.

    Every gesture in the liturgy, said Antonelli, conveys a theological idea. Courtesy of first, the Protestants, and then the modernists, the theological idea that communion in the hand came to convey was a repudiation of Catholic dogma on the Eucharist and the priesthood.

  6. ciaran
    Posted November 25, 2010 at 11:22 am | Permalink

    “Let the Jew depart, let the heathen depart!” As pointed out in a Quidlibet post, this was an authentic “bidding prayer” that an ordained deacon would have used.

    In my salad days, when, during primary school I used to serve the parish Novus Ordo, I sometimes had the opportunity of reciting the bidding prayers. So convinced was the parish priest of my decency (a layman of good character!) that sometimes I was allowed to compose the bidding prayers myself.

    Had I, in the name of antiquity, and inspired by the integrity of early Church worship, brought this bidding prayer to the lectern, that would have been the end of my days as an altar boy!

  • Buy the Book

  • Categories

  • Archives